Past Captains (1924-1952):
- Jacob Armacost (1924-1928)
- Raymond Miller (1929-1933)
- Grant Mays (1934, 1935, 1937-1939)
- Earl Palmer (1936)
- Harry Armacost (1940)
- Herbert Barrett (1941-1942)
- Howard Cole (1943-1944)
- Clyde Ensor (1945-1948)
- Arthur Hendrix (1949-1952)
Past Fire Chiefs (1953-Present):
- Elwood Leight (1953-1955, 1973-1980)
- Clyde Ensor (1956)
- Louis Stiffler (1957-1972)
- Ron Croft (1981-1983)
- Fred Stiffler (1984-1987, 1989, 1991-1994)
- Dan Bollinger (1988, 1990)
- Phil Kearney (1995)
- Chuck Bollinger (1996-2000, 2003, 2006-2019, 2023-2024)
- Tom Ruhl (2001-2002)
- Chris Lang (2004-2005)
- Taylor Russell (2020)
- Herb Taylor (2021-2022)
Past Presidents:
- Grover C. Naylor (1924)
- John H. Pocock (1925-1927)
- Emory A. Burton (1928-1933)
- Jacob Armacost (1934-1935)
- Leroy Merryman (1936)
- W. Reed Chenworth (1937)
- John T. Hicks (1938-1939, 1942)
- S. Howard Miller (1940)
- William S. Thompson (1941,1943-1944, 1948)
- Fred Snyder (1945)
- Thomas Neuberger (1946)
- Frank Molesworth (1947, 1949, 1956-1957)
- Robert Kline (1950)
- Raymond M. Miller (1951)
- Clyde Ensor (1953-1955)
- Carl Shaffer (1958-1960)
- Percy Naylor (1961-1964)
- Louis Hoshall (1965)
- Howard Rosier (1966-1967)
- Lawrence Bayne (1968, 1972-1973, 1975)
- Herbert Ford (1969-1970)
- Frank Gosnell (1971, 1992)
- Charles Robertson (1974)
- Henry Zink (1976-1978)
- Clarence Tracey (1979)
- W. Kelley Rice (1980-1981)
- Glenn Pearce (1982)
- D. Keith Whitehurst (1983)
- Jack Carter (1984-1986)
- Mark Bilger (1987-1991)
- Ron Campion (1993-1994, 2002-2004, 2017-2020)
- Robert Warns (1995)
- Wayne Smith (1996-1998,2000,2001,2005,2006,2008-2014)
- Richard Bilger (1999)
- Chuck Frederick (2007)
- Steve Gore (2015-2016)
- Tyler Bello (2021-2022)
- Charles Ray III (2023-2024)